Skip to content
HELOC Calculator
Menu

HELOC vs Home Equity Loan

Both borrow against your home. One is a fixed lump sum, the other a variable credit line. Put in the amount and both rates to see which costs less, and how much a rising HELOC rate would change it.

Updated · Prime rate 7.00%

$
years

HELOC (variable)

%
points

Try +1 or −1 to see the risk.

years

Then it repays over the rest of the term.

Home equity loan (fixed)

%

Cheaper in total interest

Home equity loan

by $5,484

HELOC: first payments
Interest only for 5 years
$333.33
HELOC: payments after that
$606.64
HELOC: total interest
$42,797
Home equity loan: every payment
$485.07
Home equity loan: total interest
$37,313

A HELOC's low interest-only payments cost more over time unless you pay principal early. The fixed loan is predictable; the HELOC follows prime.

HELOC vs home equity loan, side by side

HELOCHome equity loan
How you get the moneyDraw as neededLump sum at closing
RateVariable (prime + margin)Fixed
Early paymentsOften interest onlyPrincipal and interest
Interest charged onOnly what you've drawnThe full amount
Best forRenovations in stages, tuition, a safety netOne big cost, debt consolidation

The example

$50,000 repaid over 15 years. The HELOC is at 8% with 5 years of interest-only payments; the fixed loan is at 8.25%.

Despite the lower rate, the HELOC costs about $5,500 more because nothing is repaid for five years. If its rate averaged one point higher, the cost would reach about $48,500. Pay principal from the start and the HELOC would come out ahead. The low early payment is what you pay for.

Questions that decide it

  1. Do you need all the money now? Yes: home equity loan. In pieces: HELOC.
  2. Could you handle a payment that rises if rates do? No: fixed loan.
  3. Will you repay within a few years? Then a HELOC's flexibility usually costs less.

Have a very low mortgage rate? Borrowing on top of it with either option is often cheaper than a cash-out refinance.

HELOAN vs HELOC: the names

Lenders sometimes call a home equity loan a "HELOAN" to set it apart from a HELOC. Same product: a fixed-rate lump sum. So "HELOAN vs HELOC" and "home equity loan vs line of credit" are the same question this page answers. More on how the line works in what is a HELOC.

Questions people ask

What's the difference between a HELOC and a home equity loan?

A home equity loan (sometimes called a HELoan) gives you all the money at once, at a fixed rate, with the same payment every month. A HELOC is a credit line: you borrow what you need when you need it, at a variable rate, often paying interest only at first.

Is a HELOC or home equity loan better right now?

With prime at 7.00%, HELOCs around 8% and fixed home equity loans are close. Choose the fixed loan for one big expense and predictable payments; choose a HELOC if you'll spend in stages or repay quickly, since you only pay interest on what you draw.

Which is easier to qualify for?

About the same: enough equity, a credit score usually above 620–680, and a debt-to-income ratio the lender accepts.

Sources

More home equity calculators